Agency Tech GuideBuild my stack
Personal lines · 5 carriers

Who writes Personal umbrella

Carriers that write personal umbrella liability through independent agents, with published underlying limit and eligibility rules.

A personal umbrella adds liability limits, usually in $1 million layers, above a household's auto, homeowners, renters, condo and watercraft policies. It pays only after the underlying liability limit is used up, and it can also cover some claims the primary policies don't, such as libel and slander. The NAIC notes that an umbrella does not cover damage to the insured's own home or car, and it does not cover punitive damages tied to deliberate conduct such as drunk driving. Business pursuits and professional liability are generally excluded. Carriers require minimum underlying limits before they will write an umbrella. Triple-I says insurers typically want about $250,000 of auto liability and $300,000 of homeowners liability in place; many carriers set their own figures and some require the underlying policies to be with them. Appetite is shaped by the number and age of drivers, driving records, the number of homes and rental properties, watercraft and recreational vehicles, and exposures such as pools, trampolines and certain dogs. Umbrellas are hard to place for households with youthful drivers, major violations, many rental units, large boats, or public figures and others with heightened lawsuit exposure. Most carriers sell personal umbrellas mainly as an add-on to their own home and auto accounts, so agencies usually quote them on the carrier portal after the underlying policies are written. Standalone umbrellas over other carriers' policies go to the few markets that write them.

Carriers with published appetite

From each carrier's own public appetite guide or product pages. Appetite changes: confirm with the carrier before you submit.

Auto-Owners Insurance

Homeowners — Personal umbrella limits up to $5M, with higher limits subject to underwriting approval. Includes worldwide coverage, personal injury (libel, slander, false arrest, wrongful eviction) and care, custody and control of rented or borrowed property (Umbrella page, Oct 2026).

Quote it through: Semsee, or the carrier portal

Erie Insurance

Homeowners — Personal catastrophe liability sits above ERIE home and auto policies. ERIE says $1M of extra coverage usually costs under $20 a month. Umbrella Liability Insurance is not offered in New York, where ERIE keeps selling Personal Catastrophe Liability (Personal Umbrella Insurance page, Oct 2026).

Foremost Insurance

Homeowners — Foremost Signature Umbrella, quoted in Agent360, sits over the client's auto, home, boat and RV policies. Excess UM/UIM applies only after the underlying auto UM limit is exhausted (Signature Umbrella agent page, Oct 2026).

Grange Insurance

Homeowners — To apply for a personal umbrella, the Grange auto must carry at least $250K/$500K bodily injury and $100K property damage, and the home at least $300K personal liability. Some primary policies may need higher minimums (Personal Umbrella Insurance page, Oct 2026).

The Hartford

Homeowners — Prevail Personal Umbrella sits over Prevail Auto and Home for mature-market households with higher liability needs (Hartford agent products page, Oct 2026).

Before you submit

  • Declarations pages for every underlying auto, home, rental property and watercraft policy
  • All household drivers with dates of birth, license numbers and three to five years of violations and accidents
  • Addresses and occupancy for all owned residences and rental properties, with unit counts
  • Boats, personal watercraft, ATVs and other recreational vehicles with length and horsepower
  • Liability exposures: pools, trampolines, dogs and breeds, board or volunteer positions
  • Five years of liability claims for the household

Sources

  1. Triple-I: What is an umbrella liability policy?
  2. NAIC: What's an umbrella policy?

Updated Oct 30, 2026

Tell us your book.
We'll build your stack.

Get my free shortlist